Wednesday, December 02, 2015  Proportional Viewing Options. 800 1024 1280 1440 1680 1920 Currently Viewing - 1024 ! Port Stanley Weather
News Regional National Events Weather Community Directory Sports Real Estate Classifieds Photos Video Contact Us
Frank and Nancy Prothero Century 21 First Canadian Corp Port Stanley Festival Theatre 2013 Season Jeff Yurek, MPP click here to viewRubyeyes Kraftwerks Glass Art Studio and Shoppe
News / Editorials
More Editorials   -  1 2 More Editorials, 36 available.
Transparency or Suppression
  by Francie Dennison  
 Future of Port Stanley in the Balance
 Which Way Do I Vote ?
 Climate Summit Ignores Real Problems
 And the Plan Is ?
 Bear With Me
 Ratepayers Ultimately Foot the Bill
 Opposing Points of View on Bill C-51
 Remembering Ron Johnson
 Thanks for Missing Me
 But Was It a Fire ?
 Pet Peeve
 The Challenges that Await
 The 2014 Cost of Our Blue Flag Beach
 Central Elgin Votes
 Berm Remediation May Not Occur
 2014 Municipal Election Field of Candidates
 There is Something About September
 Small Business Tax Credit to Helps Create Jobs
 Tourist Attraction
 Issues Looming on the Horizon
 In Whose Best Interests ?
 Planned Harbour Improvements
 Transparency or Suppression 
 So You Want It Published

Mayor Walters says his push to pass a Code of Conduct for Central Elgin Council is a transparency measure, but how transparent is it really when the public has never seen this proposed Code of Conduct and have not been afforded any input into it?

When people are elected to Central Elgin Council they are sworn in using an Oath of Office which, according to a statement made by Councillor Sally Martyn in the March 24, 2014 Council meeting, governs their conduct while they are in office. I can't tell you what the Oath of Office says because, despite numerous requests over the years for a copy of it, I've never seen it and have never been able to find it published on the municipality's website.

Now we don't have a Rob Ford on our Council, someone whose questionable behaviour, that may or may not include criminal behaviour, reflects badly on the municipality. No, in Central Elgin's case the Code of Conduct push came as a direct result of Councillor Russell Matthews questioning certain spending practices engaged in by staff and approved by Council. Over this term Matthews has disagreed with certain spending decisions at budget time, and though out-voted on the issues, nonetheless raised his objections again in Open Council meetings when the issues came before Council for a deciding vote. Neither senior staff nor the rest of Council liked Matthews breaking ranks and "airing the dirty laundry", so to speak.

I don't know who first presented the Code of Conduct idea - whether it was senior staff or a member of Council - but the limited amount of discussion it's received at Council table seems to imply its primary purpose is to muzzle any dissenting Councillors from publicly expressing any opinion on anything that is not the "official" line that Council is taking on the issue, and they want to force all members of Council to abide by this Code. In my book this is the antithesis of democracy, not transparency. It seems more of a move to hide dissent from public view.

We elect our Councillors to represent our best interests and to speak out against anything proposed that they see as going against our best interests. That includes speaking out publicly and keeping us informed. That is their job, yet it seems this Code of Conduct would remove that entirely.

On March 24, 2014 Mayor Walters said he wanted it in place before this session ended so that it would bind the new Council. It raises a red flag when someone who is not running in this election is in a big hurry to pass a by-law whose express purpose is to bind members of future Councils to his will. Councillor Martyn said she does not want the Code of Conduct to duplicate the behaviours they already swear to follow when being sworn in with their Oath of Office.

If this is really a transparency measure, as Mayor Walters claims, then this is a challenge for him to have both the Oath of Office and the proposed Code of Conduct published on the front page of the municipal website where it can be easily found by the public, along with a time line inviting public comments on both. Better yet, send them through to Port Stanley and we'll publish them on our front page - now that would be true transparency.

Wednesday, December 02, 2015 | Welcome Guest! | Login | Home | Terms of Use | RSS Feeds
World's 1st Proportional Viewing News Web Site. February 5, 2008. Copyright ©
Send mail to with questions or comments about this web site.
Copyright © 2004 - 2015 Port Stanley All Rights Reserved ISSN 1718-8695